Al's Place Quantum Leap Online Community

Al's Place Quantum Leap Online Community (http://quantumleap-alsplace.com/forum/index.php)
-   Quantum Leap General Discussion (http://quantumleap-alsplace.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Season Finales Best-Worst (http://quantumleap-alsplace.com/forum/showthread.php?t=6411)

TylerMeans 09-16-2014 02:57 PM

Season Finales Best-Worst
 
How do you rate the 5 season finales of Quantum Leap? Which were good, bad, or indifferent?
I find it very odd that only one of the finales was actually a cliff hanger. Most shows nowadays always end on a cliff hanger but only the season 3 finale, "Shock Theater" was a cliff hanger that led into season 4.
So how do you rate them first to last?

5. Play it Again Seymour Just an episode. Nothing more or less
4. A Leap for Lisa entertaining and a decent hour of television
3. Shock Theater I would have rated it high just because of the cliff hanger aspects of it but I personally did not care for this episode.
2. Mirror Image As the series Finale, I find this episode very interesting and fun to watch. I did like the closure on Beth-Al but am lukewarm of hearing Sam never got home.
1. MIA Not a cliff hanger in any way but a fan favorite and touching episode. I think if we took a fan poll this episode would end up in the top two or three.

Lightning McQueenie 09-17-2014 05:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TylerMeans (Post 61440)
How do you rate the 5 season finales of Quantum Leap? Which were good, bad, or indifferent?
I find it very odd that only one of the finales was actually a cliff hanger. Most shows nowadays always end on a cliff hanger but only the season 3 finale, "Shock Theater" was a cliff hanger that led into season 4.
So how do you rate them first to last?

5. Play it Again Seymour Just an episode. Nothing more or less
4. A Leap for Lisa entertaining and a decent hour of television
3. Shock Theater I would have rated it high just because of the cliff hanger aspects of it but I personally did not care for this episode.
2. Mirror Image As the series Finale, I find this episode very interesting and fun to watch. I did like the closure on Beth-Al but am lukewarm of hearing Sam never got home.
1. MIA Not a cliff hanger in any way but a fan favorite and touching episode. I think if we took a fan poll this episode would end up in the top two or three.

I think we could say A Leap For Lisa was a cliffhanger as well, as everyone wanted to know what happened with Sam as Lee Harvey Oswald...

TylerMeans 09-17-2014 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lightning McQueenie (Post 61442)
I think we could say A Leap For Lisa was a cliffhanger as well, as everyone wanted to know what happened with Sam as Lee Harvey Oswald...


Thanks, I stand corrected. I had forgotten all about that one. Pity how only two of the finales ended with a real cliffhanger and set up the new season premiere.

Wrong Arturo 09-21-2014 07:56 AM

5. Mirror Image - I'm not a fan of this finale.
4. Play it Again Seymour - Great ep, but not really a finale per se (nor was it intended to be).
3. A Leap for Lisa
2. Shock Theater - The biggest cliffhanger. Great fun.
1. MIA - Just a beautifully crafted episode from beginning to end.

feldon30 09-21-2014 09:47 AM

Mirror Image -- watched it. Said "what the hell?" Rewound the tape and rewatched it. Walked away disgusted and didn't watch QL for years afterwards.

Shock Theater was the best finale IMO.

Wrong Arturo 09-21-2014 11:59 AM

Yeah, "Shock Theater" just had one jaw-dropping twist after another, right up to the leap at the end of the episode. For a long time, it was not only my favorite finale, but my favorite episode, period. It might still be.

But most recently, I rewatched "MIA" and it's just so satisfying on every level. The writing, the acting, the crisp direction by Michael Zinberg. "MIA" nosed out "Shock" this time, but it was a close one, and maybe on a different day, I would switch back again. :)

blue enigma 09-21-2014 07:58 PM

5. Shock Theater - I'm out of sync with everyone on this one; not a fan at all, but it's a great showcase for Scott Bakula. High marks for the acting across the board, but especially Scott.
4. A Leap for Lisa - interesting episode with some great moments, but also a ton of plotholes and the treatment of the rape/murder was kind of crappy.
3. Play it Again Seymour - though not a cliffhanger finale - I'm not sure if they even knew there would be a second season at this point - it's lots of fun and the Sam-Al interaction is great.
2. MIA - very moving episode, nice Sam-Al dynamics, fabulous showcase for Dean, and Beth is an awesome character.
1. Mirror Image - I'm out of sync with everyone on this one too. I love it, even despite the last black screen. My one and only quibble is that Al is in just 2 or 3 scenes and only 1 is with Sam (and it's way too short).

Wrong Arturo 09-22-2014 05:11 AM

You're actually not all that out of sync. Based on votes by the IMDB community, it's one of the top 5 most acclaimed episodes of all time.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0096684/...ref_=ttep_ql_3

So while it's unfathomable to me, you're not the ones out of snyc; apparently, we are. :D

QL Nut 09-27-2014 04:48 AM

5) "Play It Again, Seymour" - To be fair, this was still shot at a time where the fate of the series was uncertain. I could be completely wrong on that. But if memory serves, I do believe it would have been written more like a finale if other Season 2 episodes that were produced for Season 1 didn't air afterward. The film noir murder-mystery aspect was interesting, as was the drama between Al and Sam. But the fact still remains that I really have trouble even counting this as a finale at all.

4) "Mirror Image" - Ah, yes. Controversial. Series finale. Non-sensical (even by QL's standards). Emotional. Well, the non-sensical/metaphysical aspect is what always bothered me most about this finale, I think. I've said many times in the past that I never liked how this episode basically undermined the entire series' technology-based premise. Looking back on it all nowadays, the series had religious/spiritual undertones all along, which we all know. But it's now clearer to me than ever before to think of "Mirror Image" as science and spirituality confronting each other, along with the themes of transcendence and the metaphysical. If you look at the episode on those terms, it's truly relevant now more than ever before with anyone familiar with politics, science and religious debates. We all saw these things in plain sight, but its relevance seems more prevalent now than ever.

Even still, I could never relate to doppelgangers of people Sam previously helped (most of them weren't ghosts!) and I felt the episode was just Don Bellisario re-creating aspects of his own childhood and pulling a Stanley Kubrick 2001: A Space Odyssey (only in terms of controversial ambiguity). In other words, it felt like he was going to worry about figuring it all out later on, if there was a Season 6.

3) "A Leap For Lisa" - Now there is a lot going on in this finale. Al is actually "erased" from existence and is executed!!! We see who would have been in Al's place had he never existed. And Sam's leap-in is a dream, which was a unique spin on the traditional leap-in, which could have possibly been related to he and Al's neuron-mason crossover from "The Leap Back." Even the fate of Project Quantum Leap itself was in limbo. But, beyond all of that, I distinctly remember viewing this episode for the first time and actually wondered whether Al raped a woman in his youth and questioned his innocence! That's right, I said it. This episode struck me in a way that it put me in as much doubt as the jury in Al's own trial, briefly. Thing is, despite all of these major things going on, it still came off as 'just another episode' to a casual viewer unfamiliar with the series.

2) "Shock Theater" - What an episode. I have to say this was arguably the most exciting episode of QL. It was great nostalgia having Sam 'tap in' to the traces of past leapees. On a deeper level, yes, the overall reason for Sam being there in the first place was relatively weak (compared to most other leaps). I said in another thread that I don't believe there are trivial leaps. And this was one of the episodes I defended with the reason being more of a "butterfly effect" and/or "ripple effect" in which even the slightest change made the biggest difference later on. We know that surely Sam Bederman's life most likely did not improve. We can only hope from the context of the show that it was Bederman's fate to always be in a mental institution as he was apparently legitimately disturbed in the first place (at least, according to Al and likely Dr. Beeks). This only goes to show as another example that the person Sam has leapt into is not always the person that needs to be saved in any given way.

I always had a theory that THIS was where the TRUE mind-merging occurred for the first time. Well, why would GFTW place Sam in the helpless position to have his brain scrambled by a bogus shock therapy session in the first place? Looking on from a spiritual level, this leap was possibly a test. If GFTW was in control, "it" could have leaped Sam in whenever "it" wanted. And as "Mirror Image" implies, Sam was the one leaping himself, so was this just another targetless leap-in from his own subconscious? No one knows.

1) "M.I.A." - In the end, this episode, in my opinion, was the most poignant in the series. In the beginning we're to belive this is a 'typical' leap to save a cop from being murdered. We might normally not think much of Al's emotions toward the specifics of the leap, especially with his own deception when explaining it to Sam. (By the way, Al must never have been fond of the name Dirk. One ended up marrying the love of his life and the other saw to it that he was executed.) Ironically, the one saving grace of the finale I dislike, "Mirror Image," is that it rights the wrong of this episode. In a strange way it coexists and makes up for the sad ending.

Donofrio_QLTD 01-11-2015 06:34 AM

Now that's a tough one...

In my opinion...

Best one: A Leap For Lisa. (Among DPB's finest writings.)

Followed by (in the order they're presented):

- Shock Theater. (Shocking and intense, just how DP knew it.)

- Mirror Image. (Yes it's the finalé and it may be pretty confusing the first 100 times you watch it but it's still a classic and its weirdness it's what makes it great.)

- M.I.A. (I love it and it's a classic too and has every bit of excellence by DPB but it's really not my cup of tea.)

Worst one: Play It Again, Seymour. (Yawn! What a bore, indeed. One of the few QL eps. it's a real pain to sit through.)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:05 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2000 - 2016 Al's Place Quantum Leap Fan Site | 4.8.15.16.23.42