Yep, it happened so often that one teacher gave me top mark for my artistic work (at highschool and uni) and others barely a pass.
I haven't read your work, but I think ohboy is right too, it depends a lot on your audience and whether your style is matching with their expectations.
My theater club thought I was awful, except for a handful of people who loved what I did and next thing I knew I was accepted by 2 acting schools, one of them quite prestigeous.
Just saying, that if what you create is from the heart it's going to touch at least a few people, and if you want to reach a wider audience you may simply have to learn or practice the appropriate technique to reach them.
So keep writing, if you love it!
Although, I wouldn't mind hearing some of your music.
PS. just remembering something my boyfriend told me: "If you are an artist you have to put your work out there for everyone to see and comment on and as everyone is different there will be people who hate it and there will be unpleasant comments. As you can't change it, you should make your peace with it and focus on the feedback that is helpful."